Nonprofits play a vital role in building healthy, resilient communities. They provide essential services, create belonging, and often fill gaps that governments or the private sector can’t. But many nonprofits overlook a simple truth: you can’t ask for community support if you aren’t prepared to give it back.
A “Buy Local First” policy is more than a nice idea — it’s a strategic approach to strengthening your nonprofit’s financial sustainability, deepening community trust, and honoring the businesses who step up to support you.
In this article, we’ll explore why buying local matters, the pitfalls of ignoring it, and how nonprofits can build practical policies to make “local first” part of their DNA.
Why Nonprofits Depend on Local Business
Whether you run a youth sports league, an arts organization, or a social service agency, chances are you rely on local sponsorships and donations. Local businesses are often the first to buy program ads, donate products, or sponsor events. They see the direct impact of your work and believe in giving back.
But here’s the question every nonprofit board and leader should ask:
If we want our local businesses to invest in us, how are we investing in them?
- When your team needs catering, where do you order from?
- When your board hosts an event, where do you book the venue?
- When you buy printing, supplies, or equipment, who gets the contract?
Too often, nonprofits default to the cheapest option — sometimes an out-of-town vendor or a faceless online provider. That short-term savings comes at a long-term cost: it undermines the very businesses you count on for sponsorships and goodwill.
Reciprocity: The Heart of Community Partnership
Imagine this:
-
A local independant restaurant sponsors your youth hockey team with a $2,500 contribution.
-
At the end of the season, you host your team dinner… at a chain restaurant who doesn’t support local organizations.
What message does that send?
The restaurant that believed in your mission now feels taken for granted. The goodwill that came with their sponsorship evaporates. And next season, when you come knocking for renewal, they’ll hesitate… or worse… decline.
Nonprofits must recognize that support is a two-way street. If a local business invests in you, you should be ready to invest in them. That doesn’t mean blindly ignoring cost or quality. It means factoring community impact into every decision you make.
The Economic Case for Buying Local
This isn’t just about goodwill — it’s about economics. Studies consistently show that when dollars are spent locally:
-
They recirculate in the community, supporting other jobs and services.
-
Local businesses are more likely to sponsor community initiatives, donate to charities, and volunteer their time.
-
Communities become more resilient, less dependent on external forces.
For nonprofits, this creates a virtuous cycle: the stronger your local economy, the stronger your donor and sponsorship base.
Why Price Isn’t the Only Factor
Nonprofits often operate under tight budgets. It’s tempting to make decisions on price alone. But the lowest bid isn’t always the best value when you consider the full picture.
-
Local relationships: A nearby supplier can respond faster, customize solutions, and work with you when times are tough.
-
Visibility: Every time your organization is seen supporting a local business, it reinforces your commitment to community.
-
Reputation: Funders and sponsors notice when nonprofits align their spending with their mission.
Boards should encourage staff to ask: What is the long-term benefit of this purchase? Sometimes an extra 10% spent locally yields far greater returns in loyalty, trust, and sponsorships.
A Practical “Buy Local First” Framework
So how can nonprofits formalize this idea? Here’s a framework you can adapt into policy:
1. Define “Local”
-
Set a geographic boundary (e.g., within your municipality, county, or region).
-
For rural nonprofits, you may need a wider radius.
2. Prioritize Local Suppliers in Procurement
-
Always seek at least one local quote before choosing an outside vendor.
-
Use a weighted scoring system that considers community impact, not just cost.
3. Tie Sponsorships to Purchasing Decisions
-
If a business sponsors your nonprofit, commit to considering them first for relevant purchases.
-
Encourage board members and families to personally support sponsor businesses.
4. Educate Your Team and Volunteers
-
Share a “sponsor directory” with parents, volunteers, and staff.
-
Make it easy for your community to give back to those who support you.
5. Communicate Your Commitment
-
Let funders, donors, and the public know you’ve adopted a Buy Local First policy.
-
Highlight stories of how supporting local businesses has created mutual benefit.
Overcoming Common Objections
“But the local option is more expensive.”
Sometimes true. But consider total value: local vendors often provide better service, flexibility, and sponsorships that offset costs. At the very minimum, give your local vendors an opportunity to price match if all things are equal.
“Our nonprofit is too small to make a difference.”
Not true. A single team dinner, printing order, or catering contract can mean a lot to a small business.
“We don’t have time to source locally.”
Build a list once, update annually. Over time, this actually saves effort.
Case Study: Youth Sports Sponsorships
Take the example of a youth soccer club. Their biggest sponsors are local restaurants, dentists, and small retailers. But if families never visit those restaurants or shop at those stores, sponsorships become transactional — and fragile.
Now imagine the club implements a Buy Local First policy:
-
All team dinners are held at sponsor restaurants.
-
Families are encouraged to “support those who support us.”
-
The club publicizes sponsor businesses on social media.
The result? Sponsors see a clear return on investment, renew year after year, and even increase their support. Families feel more connected to the community. And the club reduces its reliance on constantly chasing new sponsors.
The Governance Angle: Why Boards Must Lead
This isn’t just an operational issue — it’s a governance responsibility. Boards are stewards of mission and reputation. Adopting a Buy Local First policy demonstrates:
-
Alignment with mission: supporting community well-being.
-
Ethical stewardship: showing that financial decisions reflect community values.
-
Sustainability: building long-term sponsor loyalty and local resilience.
Boards should treat Buy Local First as part of their fiduciary and strategic duty — not just a nice-to-have.
How IntraVista Strategic Consulting Can Help
At IntraVista, we help nonprofits translate values into action. A Buy Local First policy is one way to align your governance, operations, and financial practices with your mission.
We can support you in:
-
Designing procurement policies that balance cost and community impact.
-
Coaching boards on integrating “local first” into their governance.
-
Building sponsor engagement strategies that maximize mutual benefit.
Your nonprofit can’t thrive in isolation. Strengthening local businesses strengthens you.
Conclusion
Nonprofits ask their communities for support every day — donations, sponsorships, volunteers. But true partnership is reciprocal. If your nonprofit wants local businesses to show up for you, you must show up for them.
A Buy Local First policy isn’t just good ethics. It’s good strategy. It builds stronger relationships, strengthens your local economy, and ensures the long-term sustainability of your mission.
So next time you book a team dinner, order catering, or sign a service contract, ask yourself:
Are we supporting those who support us?
That simple question could transform your nonprofit’s relationship with its community.
0 Comments